When it comes to seafood, Pennsylvania might not be the first place that springs to mind. However, this state is home to some hidden gems offering fresh and delicious seafood that rivals coastal cities. If you’re craving quality fish and shellfish dishes, these underrated spots are definitely worth a road trip. The locals love them, but many food lovers still haven’t discovered these tasty treasures.
Whether you want classic crab cakes, oysters fresh from the coast, or innovative seafood dishes, Pennsylvania’s seafood scene has something special for everyone. These eight restaurants provide a perfect blend of great flavors, cozy atmosphere, and reasonable prices. Let’s dive into where you can find the best seafood in Pennsylvania, as recommended by experts and food lovers alike.
1. The Lowertown Line – Philadelphia
The Lowertown Line is a relaxed, casual seafood spot in Philadelphia known for its fresh oysters and seasonal fish. Its menu focuses on locally sourced seafood prepared simply to highlight the natural flavors. Food critics from Philly Mag have praised their oyster selection and clam chowder, making it a must-visit for seafood fans in the city.
2. Hooked Up Seafood Shack – Pittsburgh
Hooked Up Seafood Shack serves up classic Southern-style seafood dishes with a twist, right in Pittsburgh. Their crab boil and shrimp po’boys are crowd favorites. You’ll appreciate the friendly vibe and generous portions. This spot is great for those looking to enjoy fresh seafood without leaving the city limits.
3. Dockside Willie’s – Erie
Dockside Willie’s offers lakeside views along with fantastic seafood dishes in Erie. Famous for its perch sandwich and fresh fish fry, this restaurant combines great food with a scenic setting. According to local reviews on TripAdvisor, it’s a popular but underrated choice for visitors exploring the Erie area.
4. McClure’s Pickles – Philadelphia
Although McClure’s is more famous for its pickles, it also features a small but dedicated seafood menu that includes house-smoked fish and seafood sandwiches. For those who love a fusion of flavors, it offers unique taste experiences you won’t find at ordinary seafood restaurants. Its fresh, local sourcing is appreciated by food bloggers and experts alike.
5. Rumor Mill Bar & Grille – Lancaster
Rumor Mill Bar & Grille in Lancaster is a hidden gem offering delightful seafood dishes alongside American classics. Their crab cakes and calamari receive high praise for both flavor and freshness. This friendly, unpretentious place is perfect for a casual night out and often flies under the radar, according to food enthusiasts.
6. 21st Street Coffee and Sushi – Pittsburgh
While primarily known for sushi, 21st Street Coffee and Sushi incorporates some of the freshest seafood in their creative sushi rolls and small plates. It’s a unique spot combining seafood lovers’ wishes with a cozy café atmosphere. Reviews on Yelp highlight its fresh ingredients and skilled preparation, making it a future favorite for fans of sushi and seafood.
7. Safe Harbor Seafood – Philadelphia
Safe Harbor Seafood offers an authentic East Coast seafood experience in Philadelphia, emphasizing wild-caught and sustainable ingredients. Their lobster rolls and soft-shell crab dishes stand out for their quality and authenticity, which many local food critics have noted as worthy of a visit. Sustainability and freshness make this place a top pick for conscious eaters.
8. The Wharf Rat – Pittsburgh
The Wharf Rat in Pittsburgh is a casual seafood pub serving hearty portions of fried fish, clams, and shrimp. Known for its friendly service and delicious comfort food, it’s a great option for those wanting classic seafood options without the fuss. Various local food guides recommend it for a satisfying, affordable meal.
Exploring Pennsylvania’s seafood restaurants is a rewarding experience for food lovers willing to venture beyond the well-known places. Whether you’re in a city or a small town, these underrated spots provide authentic and fresh seafood delights at reasonable prices. Make your next trip memorable by trying one or more of these hidden seafood gems.
